Sin in the Sixties: Catholics and Confession 1955–1975
Digital Logos Edition
Overview
Confession reached its peak attendance in the early 1950s, but by the end of the Second Vatican Council, the popularity of the sacrament plummeted. While this decline is often noted by historians, theologians, priests, and laity alike—all eager to provide possible explanations—little attention has been paid to another dramatic shift. Coincident with the decreasing popularity of the sacrament of penance in the United States were changes to non-sacramental penitential practices, including Lenten fasting, Ember Days, and the year-round Friday meat abstinence. American Catholics—sometimes derisively called Fisheaters—had assiduously observed Friday abstinence, regardless of ethnicity or geographic location.
In 1966, the bishops in the United States released a statement implementing Pope Paul VI's apostolic constitution on penance. Eating meat on Friday transformed from being a mortal sin to not being regarded as sinful at all. This apparently overnight change to one of the most long-standing practices, one that could be used to identify Catholics in the U.S., confused many of the faithful and resulted in Fridays becoming just another day.
The decline of the sacrament is best seen within the context of the decline of a larger penitential culture among American Catholics, and both are best understood in reference to the changing notion of sin at this time period. Sin became a more abstract, general concept, contrasting sharply with the actual and personal "shopping list" of sins that the faithful had frequently enumerated in earlier decades. Accompanying this change in the perception of sin were criticisms of the practice of penance, and both sacramental and non-sacramental penance were found wanting as both legalistic and superficial. The attempts to revitalize penance through greater choice—whether in the confessional or on Fridays—actually furthered the decline in American penitential practice.
For some, penitential practices are the buried treasure of the church that await rediscovery. For others, they were experiences that had to be endured and that are best forgotten. Morrow, in a thoughtful, even-handed way, traces how the perception and emphasis changed during this critical and controversial time in the church's history.
This is a Logos Reader Edition. Learn more.
- Seeks to contribute to the discussion surrounding the sacrament of penance by placing it in a broader context
- Considers the sacrament of penance at its height as one among many penitential practices regularly observed by the faithful during the sixties
- Emphasizes the early understanding as to the importance of sin and the recognition of one's personal, actual sin, suggesting that this idea changed during the sixties
- Sin and Penance: Interwoven History of Interwoven Concepts
- From Actual and Personal to Relative and General: The Change in Lay Catholics' Conception of Sin
- From Responsibility to Freedom: Changes in the Conception of Sin among Theologians
- Penance in a New Land: Developments in Nonsacramental Penitential Practice
- To Eat Meat or Not?: Pa enitemini. the NCCB's Pastoral Statement, and the Decline of Penance
- Thinking outside the Box: The Decline of Sacramental Confession
"Morrow's account is both thorough and accessible… Morrow's book will have wide-ranging appeal. Scholars of American Catholicism, students in courses on Catholicism, and nonacademic readers interested in the changing history of a Catholic sacrament will find much to appreciate in this book."
K. A. Dugan, Springfield College, CHOICE
"Morrow makes a valiant attempt at situating self-imposed sufferings as a means toward the expurgation of sin. Borrowing from Robert Orsi, who has written about pain disciplining the ego, Catholic practices as variegated as novenas, Lenten fast and abstinence, regular Friday abstinence, first Friday devotions, parish missions and the like are all meant to generate attentiveness to sacrifice and the sublimation of self in favor of God. In so doing, Morrow surveys a deep and creative wellspring of Catholic activity in response to sin. The book should be in graduate and seminary libraries and may do well in seminars on American Catholicism or liturgics."
Hayes, Patrick J., Horizons: The Journal of the College Theology Society
"Sin in the Sixties is the first convincing, historical-critical analysis of the transformation of the concept of sin within the larger context of the decline in sacramental and non-sacramental penitential practices in American Catholicism during the cultural, social, and theological changes of the period. Unlike some earlier studies of the decline of the sacrament of penance in the post-Vatican II era, Morrow places that decline in conjunction with the multiple internal reforms in fasting, abstinence, and other non-sacramental penitential practices. Her analysis demonstrates not only the gains that were achieved by the modifications but also the unintended damages that were done to the overall Catholic penitential tradition. This well-written, carefully researched, and provocative study is a must-read for American Catholics and the general reading public, as well as for scholars of American religious traditions."
Patrick Carey, Emeritus Professor, Marquette University