Christopher. Stewart
- Issues with Dr. Heizer Unseen realm The God of the Old Testament was part of an assembly – a pantheon – of other gods” (p. 11). Yahweh as the supreme God, the creator of all the other gods (p. 34) He believes that, at some point, God created a divine family but never says when (pp. 25, 37) Heiser sees believers being made divine and joining the divine council in the unseen realm (pp. 159, 310-311, 355) He uses Babylonian myths to draw unprovable connections from extra biblical sources (pp. 198-199). Heiser theorizes that the serpent who deceived Eve was living in Eden as a member in good standing of God’s divine council until he became displeased by God’s decision to create humanity and give them dominion over the earth. In an act of defiance, he decides to sabotage God’s plan and in the process was expelled from both the divine council and Eden (pp. 74, 82). the Satan” is a member in good standing of God’s divine council who is simply doing a job assigned to him by God (pp. 57, 91) Non literal day creation Hermeneutics is not literal grammatical or historical Was my loyalty to the text or to Christian tradition? Did I really have to choose between the two? I wasn’t sure, but I knew that what I was reading in Psalm 82, taken at face value, simply didn’t fit the theological patterns I had always been taught. (page 12) Uses small quantity of biblical language texts to prove points (Coptic, Syriac...ect)
- Interesting. I thought it was quite literal, historical and grammatical in all respects. I suspect most conservatives will struggle with the fact that Mr. Heiser does not subscribe to only interpreting Scripture with Scripture but chooses to step outside of the Bible and into the wider corpus of works that inform the reader to the various times, ways of thinking and modes of writing in which the ancient texts came to be. It can be an unsettling thing when believers see that the writings of Israel are not as disconnected from their time and place as people would like them to be.
- The criticism presented here is lacking any type of precision, it is devoid of meaningful articulated responses to the disagreements the writer brings up. This is a very coherent book with prestigious peer-reviewed citations. The footnotes and annotation are from the highest caliber theologians in Christianity and Judaism. The author is not presenting anything from a private interpretation of scriptural, apocryphal and Ancient Near East texts; rather he brilliantly creates a pastiche of the scholarship of many unassailable sources. The author is a former Resident Scholar at Logos Software. Dr. Heiser is strongly supported by Faithlife/Logos/Lexham who went so far as to release a one-hour and ten-minute video in support of Unseen Realm. The Lexham English Bible, Lexham Bible Dictionary, Logos Factbook and various other aspects of Faithlife explain and support the information in Dr. Heiser’s book. This certainly doesn’t mean Unseen Realm is true but it is a proposition that is well-attested and is filtering down from academia to the Church as a whole. You can find many YouTube videos of Dr. Heiser answering questions, exegeting various books of the Bible, being interviewed, teaching a class and so on. He also has the Naked Bible podcast. Watch or listen to some and get a feel for the guy.
- , Thank you for your summary. I appreciated your truncated and cited quotes which tell me what I needed to know about making my purchase.