
Harlan P. Hock Jr
- Finally a Rev Garrigou-Lagrange book. He is considered a Strict Thomist, and is my favorite author. This book of essays put together and translated by Dr. Matthew Minerd became my favorite of Garrigou and is my most referenced work I have of him. E.g., pp156ff has a chart of the 6 acts of the intellect beside the six acts of the will to show the logical progression in making a decision and acting on it. It's titled the Order of Intention.
- Sweet! Finally a faithful translation from all the top tier Catholic philosophers and theologians of today. Understanding Aquinas's works takes much more than just reading his works. You have to be entrenched in not only the philosophical terminology of that day, but even more importantly you need to know what the words we use today originally meant. Words like speculative/practical, per se/accident, object/subject, etc. have completely more lucid (etymology: "bright, shining" not just clear as our current language waters it down to be) meaning in scholastic philosophy. Those that have translated these works know it well. I've been amused at others (atheist, arrogant college kid) who have quickly dismissed Aquinas because they read his five ways in the Summa Theologiae (it is not Theologica) and believe they have found holes in his logic, or is just simply wrong. My atheist friend even told me even his young teenage kids could quickly find holes in his theory. The S.Th. is an advanced work assuming you already have the Aristotelian and scholastic philosophical background, as opposed to modern philosophy starting with Descartes. If you think something you read is silly you need to ask a traditional scholastic/Thomistic philosopher first. Try Dr. Matthew Minerd who loves to help.
- Almost finished with this course, but will keep referring back to it. Out of all the courses Logos offers this appeared to be the most interesting to me and original in content. Others that looked interesting at first appeared to be very long winded and uninformative in the sample videos (even the $600 ones). This one is packed with relevant info and examples, which is typical of all of Runge's videos. Also several videos show how to setup Logos filters to see the course topics appear in the Bible...really cools stuff! Certainly well worth it.
- Thanks for your response. Purchasing based on this review and the webinar the other day. I have seen other good Logos courses on subscriptions, but I am particular about purchasing things I will want to refer to multiple times or not have a time limit on. Your comments seem helpful.