• Further to my comment below about missing punctuation, here's the big problem: Whenever a short pause/semicolon (raised dot) occurs immediately before a verse reference number--which is pretty frequently!--the dot is missing. This is such a serious defect that, in my opinion, this edition should not be on the market. I bought this without knowing about this error and feel that I was taken advantage of. I use it for the (poorly presented) apparatus, but have to keep the 4th edition open, which is what I use when displaying the text in class. Because the text and the apparatus are separate books in the Logos edition (which is helpful), you can synch the apparatus to whatever text or version you are using.
    1. I am asking our team to investigate the issues that you have raised in your review.
  • Needs to be updated with corrections. There are several significant problems. For example, punctation is missing in places (e.g. Matt 18:33; Matt 22:29). Also, the critical apparatus is poorly designed. Text-critical notes lack the corresponding footnote number that it is in the text. This is difficult when there are more than one variant in a single verse, and even more difficult because this edition has no faint line (as in the printed version) or even a blank line to clearly separate variant units. A similar problem obtains with the discourse segmentation apparatus, which simply follows the text-critical apparatus without a blank line or a faint line to separate it from the previous paragraph. This forces the reader to scan the apparatus very carefully to see where one TC note ends another begins, and where the TC note ends and discourse segmentation note begins. Looks like they rushed to get this electronic edition published.
    1. The problem seems to be that the minor stop (the raised dot) is missing whenever it occurs at the end of a verse, immediately preceding the numerical verse reference of the next verse. I haven't checked the entire NT, but this is consistent through Matthew and I've spot checked elsewhere and this seems to be accurate.
    2. MVH, I was going to purchase this for a graduate class in Greek. Without the corrections, this edition is not going to be sufficient. Thank you.
  • It's a shame that this book (and many others) can't be purchased individually. There have been dozens of times that I would have purchased a particular book, but couldn't because it could only be purchased as part of an expensive bundle. No other online book seller does this, and I'm sure it's costing Logos sales.